Frozen in Time
A new documentary reveals America’s greatest entertainment:
A story of obsession, family, and faded glory—on ice.
(page 2 of 2)
Blakey lives in this building, in the back—a magical kingdom of Asian antiques: intricately carved dressers, an immense sitting platform, wall-size decorations. His living quarters were profiled in the Star Tribune’s Homes section a few years back.
But in the basement, and spilling everywhere else, is his collection of ice-skating memorabilia, almost certainly the largest in the world. Blakey began collecting soon after seeing that Sonja Henie movie in 1941. Now he has Henie’s costumes, white figure skates, and even her glittery bra, which he shows me with a mixture of awe and bemusement. There are enormous feathered headdresses and huge posters for ice shows in Germany, Russia, Japan, America, and elsewhere. There are programs from hotel revues, tabletop advertisements, publicity photos, promotional lunchboxes, toy figurines.
No museum has such a collection. “Jazz, vaudeville,” Blakey says. “Every other American art form has been documented. But no one has this history.”
It’s a fact that has motivated Pickett. Aside from the narrative pleasures of her film, it also serves as an advertisement: Stable home needed for memories, posters, shimmery bra. No skating experience required.
To take the collection out of Minnesota would be to pluck it from its native habitat. Theatrical ice skating may have taken root in Russia, a cousin to ballet, but it flowered in Minnesota. In the depths of the Great Depression, a St. Paul rink rat named Roy Shipstad began staging impromptu ice shows on local ponds—cheap entertainment—with his older brother, Eddie, and their friend, Oscar Johnson. Johnson played the clown; Eddie was a slick Fred Astaire type, complete with top hat. They were a hit and took the act on the road in 1936. They were booked at a Chicago hotel as a “tank show,” and eventually became the best-known act in the biz: the Ice Follies. In 1945, another Minnesotan, Morris Chalfen, bought the rival Holiday on Ice enterprise and headquartered it on Nicollet Avenue in Minneapolis, just south of downtown. (He’s also known for buying the Detroit Gems basketball team and relocating them to Minneapolis as the Lakers.) It was with Chalfen’s troupe that Blakey toured the world.
Pickett tracked down dozens of people like this from skating’s golden age who had melted into obscurity. Some have died since Pickett interviewed them. Her window of opportunity was closing as fast she could open it. “This may be the Ballet Russes of ice skating,” she says, comparing her film to the 2005 documentary about the Russian dancers who birthed modern ballet. Hardly anyone in either film is younger than 70 years old; most are over 80.
When skaters die, Blakey generally hears about it. He has come into a lot of artifacts this way, though he admits feeling uncomfortable approaching survivors: “You can’t just say, ‘I’m sorry he died, can I have his stuff?’” Generally, he doesn’t have to. Word of his collection has gotten out, and every so often he’ll take delivery of box after box of costumes and programs and photos, and his space closes in on him a little bit more.
Last year, Blakey appeared on PBS’s Antiques Roadshow with his Sonja Henie costumes, and one of the show’s appraisers is visiting this spring to assess his entire collection. She may not know what she’s in for. Blakey once tried to catalog his collection, typing with two fingers. But for the past year, he has paid a college student, more versed in technology than he is, to come in a few days a week and take stock.
Blakey didn’t always spend his time like this, living in the past. For most of his life, he was an active participant in the zeitgeist, first in skating and then in photography, retiring his cameras just a couple of years ago. In his studio, his previous life is manifested mostly in the framed photos on the walls of Broadway dancers and actors, and a wallet-size image, tucked into shelving on Pickett’s side of the building, of a hirsute naked man covering his privates. After retiring from the skating circuit in the 1960s, Blakey opened a studio in New York and became known for his pioneering artistic images of male nudes, compiled in a 1972 book, HE. “His studio was up a steep stairwell in Chelsea,” recalls one of his subjects, marveling at Blakey’s athleticism, “and he would virtually run down the stairs to let you in and then dash back up the hill like a little leprechaun.” Even with his skates off, Blakey moved as though on ice.
By then, the ice age was melting. Competitive ice skating was heating up, narrated on television so that anyone could thrill to the pursuit of perfection. Flipping through a scrapbook from his Hilton days, Blakey recalls how spectacle was displaced by the dry drama of points, theatrical skating by its prim alter ego—“technical skating,” he says dismissively, not looking up from his memories. “Eventually, people cared more about the Olympic champions than some random Ice Capades girl.” The only touring theatrical troupes now are Scott Hamilton’s Stars on Ice and, in a kind of subgenre, Disney on Ice.
“It’s heartbreaking to me,” Blakey says. He pauses to look at a postcard from a 1915 performance by a German skating troupe. It was at the Hippodome in New York, the largest theater in the world. “There were dancing horses and comedians,” he recounts. “For the third act, an ice-skating ballet. Snow was falling. The scenery was snow-clad mountains. America had never seen such a show.”