Edit ModuleShow Tags

Top 6 Non-Heart-Shaped Chocolates For Valentine's Day


B.T. McElrath, chocolate, twin cities
B.T. McElrath chocolates, photo by Jason DeRusha

I’m not sure why Valentine’s Day always means chocolates. I mean, why can’t it mean ice cream? Or muesli? I don’t make the rules. The truth is, chocolate and candy is a big deal. Americans are expected to spend $20 billion for Valentine’s Day in 2016, and half of Americans buy candy.

You can do better than a heart-shaped box of chocolate, though. Surdyk’s Cheese Shop in northeast Minneapolis is one of my favorite spots to buy chocolate. I asked Mary Richter, the culinary director and head chocolate/candy buyer to help me put together a list of the top five chocolate gifts for Valentine’s Day.


1. Mademoiselle Miel Honey Bon Bons

Susan Brown used to be an art museum curator, now she creates a different type of art. I profiled her company on WCCO last year. She gets honey from rooftops in Minneapolis and St. Paul, and creates gorgeous chocolates and inventive flavors. ($14.99 for 8-piece gift box, Surdyk’s)

2. B.T. McElrath Truffles

Brian McElrath is a local legend in artisan chocolate, and one of the first to bring a chef-driven approach to the food. The Salty Dog bar is delicious, the Super Red as well, but the box of Epicurean truffles is a great gift—nine pieces, including passion fruit, balsamic-zinfandel, chile-limon, among others, will not disappoint. ($19 for truffles, Surdyk’s)

(B.T. McElrath merged with Minnesota’s Annie B’s this year. Owner Amanda Henke is holding pop-up shops with boxes of caramels and truffles at Flirt Boutique in St. Paul on Feb. 11 from 5-8 p.m., Feb. 13 from 12-4 p.m., and at Fleur de Lis Flower Shop on Feb. 12 from 12:30-5 p.m., and Feb. 13 from 9-5 p.m.)

3. Rogue Chocolatier Single-Bean Bars

Colin Gasko started producing his chocolate bars in Minneapolis, now he’s in Massachusetts—close enough to be one of us. Experience a variety of fresh, high quality flavor, with the beans coming straight from farmers and producers. I love the Jamaica bar. They’re expensive, but worth it. ($14, Kopplin’s Coffee in St. Paul)

Not Local, But Still Good:

4. Recchiuti Confections

From San Francisco, the elegant and beautifully packaged chocolate morsels were made to impress. Selections include champagne truffles, Fleur de Sel caramels, and a whole lot more. “Recchiuti’s red wine and whiskey pairing truffles are typical sell outs here in the shop,” said Richter.  ($25/box, Surdyk’s)

5. Olive and Sinclair’s Duck Fat Caramels and Muzzleloaders

Yes, this is from Tennessee. The duck fat caramel is a combo of caramelized cane sugar and duck fat! Crazy! A Muzzleloader is a classic southern treat: it’s a dark chocolate shell with a liquid salted bourbon caramel inside. ($19 duck fat caramels, $18 Muzzleloaders, Surdyk’s)

6. Alma Chocolates

If you insist on the classic heart shapes, at least skip the tacky heart-shaped box. Located in Portland, Alma creates beautiful single-estate dark chocolates filled with hazelnut praline, salted caramel, or passion fruit caramel. And yes, they’re heart-shaped. ($14, Sugar Sugar Candy)


Surdyk’s, 303 E. Hennepin Ave., Minneapolis, 612-379-3232, surdyks.com
Kopplin’s Coffee, 2038 Marshall Ave., St. Paul, 651-698-0457, kopplinscoffee.com
Sugar Sugar Candy, 3803 Grand Ave. S., Minneapolis, 612-823-0261, sugarsugar-candy.com

Edit ModuleShow Tags

About This Blog

Minnesota Monthly's Taste Blog answers your restaurant and dining questions, dishes on latest discoveries, reflects on breaking news, and generally brings the plate to the page with a skilled crew of experts: Learn more about the Taste bloggers.

Have a food-related question? Email rhutton@mnmo.com

Edit ModuleShow Tags
Edit ModuleShow Tags

More »Taste Blog

DeRusha's 8 Best Twin Cities Sports Bars

Why watch the game over food you don't love? Food critic Jason DeRusha lists eight of the top sports bars in Minneapolis and St. Paul.

Oatmeal Irish Soda Bread Recipe

Fresh, homemade bread is faster and easier than you think with dough that mixes in five minutes and needs no time to rise

Hello Pizza Turns 5, Ann Kim Short-listed for James Beard Award

Hello Pizza might have middle-child syndrome next to Ann Kim's other pizza shops—but this is what makes it worth revisiting

2018 James Beard Award Finalists

Minnesota chefs stay prominent in the James Beard shortlist

Brews for Good

Guinness is donating $1 to charity for each adult that dons a ‘stache and shares on social media now through March 31, 2018

3 Reasons to Brunch This Weekend

Elegant N/A drinks, outstanding oeufs, and the best of ’80s hair rock this weekend

Blueberry-Walnut Squares Recipe

Enjoy a double-dose of antioxidants with walnuts and blueberries in this treat

Oscar Party Appetizers

Elevate your table with a trio of jazzed up party bites for a win in the best supporting snacks category

Exploring Washington Wines

Sample and discover delicious wines from our country’s second-largest wine-producing area at the Food & Wine Experience March 3 and 4
Edit ModuleShow Tags
Edit ModuleShow Tags