Edit ModuleShow Tags

The Not-So-New Trend of No Reservations


Published:

 

Half hr wait at 7:45 on a Saturday? @hi_lo_diner has a hit on its hands!

A photo posted by Minnesota Monthly (@mnmomag) on

 

I spent a lot of time waiting for a table this month. I do it for you, of course. I do it for my gig reviewing here at Minnesota Monthly. Truth be told, if it wasn’t for this job, I’m not sure I’d ever go to a restaurant that didn’t take reservations.

I hate to call it a “new” trend. Around here when Tilia opened in 2011 without reservations, that quickly became the place to wait for a table. I waited there for almost 90 minutes once, although with its fantastic beer selection and welcoming bar, that 90 minutes felt more like 45. This month I’ve waited at Mucci’s (40 seats), Handsome Hog (66 seats), and Hi-Lo Diner (70 seats). Add Revival and Saint Dinette to the list of no-reservation spots in town.

Mucci’s was 30 minutes on a Wednesday night at 6 p.m., Hi-Lo was 30 minutes on a Thursday night at 6:30 p.m., and Handsome Hog was 80 minutes on a Saturday night at 6:15 p.m. Mucci’s and Hi-Lo was with our two kids as well, which was a true exercise in their patience.

Why do restaurants do this? A lot of reasons. If you can’t make a reservation, you can’t not show up for a reservation. No-shows cost restaurants money because successful spots are in effect turning someone else away from that seat. And it’s hard to fault the restaurants: we are lining up at these spots, we are packing the places with more diners than would eat there if there were reservations.

New technology has made waiting a little easier. All of these restaurants use iPad systems that will text you when your table is ready, and show you the queue so you know how many people are in front of you in line.

But it’s not very hospitable, is it? What hospitality is there when you have to stack up near the entrance of a place, or wait outside until you get to enter the temple? Isn’t there a middle ground here—maybe make people put down a credit card for a reservation and then charge no-shows? Maybe allow some reservations?

When you have kids, you’re already paying a babysitter to enjoy a night out at a great restaurant. Now you’re also paying to wait. This mostly seems to be a young person’s game, I don’t know a lot of people over the age of 45 willing to wait in line. Someone help me understand why it makes sense to have a restaurant designed to be welcoming and pleasurable and an escape to the diner—but then makes you line up and stand there for more than an hour?

Edit ModuleShow Tags

Related Articles

The Strip Club's J.D. Fratzke and Republic's Matty O'Reilly's new St. Paul joint is open

Restaurateur Matty O'Reilly says, enough Italian—the west side of St. Paul could use a little French tavern

Shrimp, Red Pepper and Feta Mini Tarts Recipe

Dressed-to-impress mini tarts are a breeze with frozen puff pastry

Blackbird Still Soars Above the Rest

The pioneer of south Eat Street still flies high
Edit ModuleShow Tags

About This Blog

TC Taste answers your restaurant and dining questions, dishes on latest discoveries, reflects on breaking news, and generally brings the plate to the page with a skilled crew of experts: Learn more about the TC Taste bloggers.

Have a food-related question? Email rhutton@mnmo.com

Edit ModuleShow Tags
Edit ModuleShow Tags

Recent TC Taste Posts

Shrimp, Red Pepper and Feta Mini Tarts Recipe

Dressed-to-impress mini tarts are a breeze with frozen puff pastry

Three Things to Eat This Week: March 21–27

Comfort foods to carry us into spring

Quality Food for the Suburbs from Great Families

Venezuelan immigrants bring their home food to the Twin Cities

Irish Soda Bread with Dried Cherries and Golden Raisins Recipe

The addition of dried cherries lends fresh flavors to this homespun Irish soda bread.

Want Some Cheese with that Wine?

It’s like a happy couple—wine and cheese bring out the best in each other
Edit ModuleShow Tags
Edit ModuleShow Tags