I’ve read Americans eat more ice cream than citizens of any other country in the world, and nobody can claim my family and I don’t do our part. During the summer months, we head, nearly every night, to one ice cream shop or another, ending most evenings with a cone; nothing fancy, no sundaes, no sprinkles, or waffle cones—just a simple cone. By this time in August, our sugar consumption reaches unsustainable levels, and I question the logic of transforming a treat into a daily bread. And then there is the cost. Though not an extravagant luxury, daily trips to the ice cream shop force some monetary inquiries not dissimilar to the, “do I really need a latte everyday” line of questioning, and “maybe it’s best not to know how much I spend per month on beer.”
Recently I started keeping a tally, made a few calls to ice cream shops, and came up with some numbers. Here is a non-quality based, incomplete, and purely monetary tally of what a person shells out for a cone/cup* at some of my favorite ice cream shops.
Izzy’s | $4.64 per cone, 5 oz. scoop (actually 4, plus Izzy scoop) | 93 cents per oz. |
Crema (Sonny’s) | $3.70 per cone, 4 oz. scoop | 93 cents per oz. |
Grand Ole Creamery | $4.90 per cone, 6 oz. scoop | 82 cents per oz. |
Sebastian Joe’s | $4.85 per cone, 6 oz. scoop | 81 cents per oz. |
Ben & Jerry’s | $3.94 per cone, 6 oz. scoop | 66 cents per oz. |
Nelson’s | $4.50 filled cone, plus softball sized scoop (estimated 8 oz.) | 56 cents per oz. |
Yogurt Lab | $2.88 for 6 oz. | 48 cents per oz. |
Conny’s Creamy Cone** | $1.85 per cone, 6 oz. scoop | 31 cents per oz. |
Dairy Queen** | $1.49 per cone, 5 oz. scoop | 30 cents per oz. |
Cup and Cone** | $1.26 per cone, 6 oz. scoop | 21 cents per oz. |
*I used the basic cone or cup as the comparative measure—a single, not a kiddie, or some other insulting amount of ice cream, large or small.
**Soft serve ice cream uses cheaper ingredients and sells at a cheaper price than homemade ice cream and might prove an unfair, albeit tasty and satisfying, comparison.